I am not asking to be selected, I am asking for answers,

Image for I am not asking to be selected, I am asking for answers,

India's top paddler just dropped a statement that's shaking Indian sport.

And no — she's not begging for a spot.

She's demanding answers.

Manika Batra — World No. 51, former Commonwealth Games singles gold medallist, the woman who put Indian table tennis on the global map — has been left out of the Aichi-Nagoya Asian Games squad.

Named only as a reserve.

Her response? Pure fire.

"I am not asking to be selected. I am not asking anyone to overturn the decision. I am asking for answers."


⚡ The math that broke her

Here's the absurd part.

Batra is sitting at World No. 51.

Just 3 ranking points behind the World No. 50 cutoff that earns automatic qualification.

That's it. Three points. A rounding error in a rolling rankings system.

👉 "If an athlete who has consistently been around the Top 50 moves from 50 to 51 over a week or two, does that suddenly make her ineligible?" she asked.

Fair question.


🎯 The case she's building

Batra isn't just venting. She came with receipts:

  • 🏓 Recent wins over top Asian and Chinese players
  • 🥇 A Commonwealth Games singles gold (2018) — the first ever by an Indian woman
  • 🥉 An Asian Games medal already on her resume
  • 📋 Sports ministry guidelines that emphasise current form in selections

And then she pointed at the door next to hers.

Ayhika Mukherjee — part of India's historic women's doubles bronze at the 2022 Hangzhou Asian Games — also dropped.

"When athletes with such achievements are left out, it naturally raises questions," Batra said.


🗳️ The vote nobody will explain

This is where it gets spicy.

Batra says she was told the squad was finalised through a vote by the selection committee.

So she's asking the questions nobody wants on record:

  • Who voted?
  • What were their reasons?
  • Any conflicts of interest declared?
  • What are the qualifications of the people picking national teams?

The federation's defence? She skipped domestic events, so she doesn't feature in national rankings.

Her counter: international players juggle a brutal global calendar, visas, recovery. That's the job.


🔥 The escalation

She's not stopping at a press statement.

Letters have gone out to PM Narendra Modi and Sports Minister Mansukh Mandaviya.

And if the answers don't come?

She'll explore "all remedies available" — including legal action.

She even reminded everyone she's done this before — her past pushback triggered governance reforms in Indian table tennis. "Would have miffed a certain few," she noted, dryly.


🧠 The real story

This isn't really about one squad sheet.

It's about whether Indian athletes get to know why doors close on them.

Whether selection is a process — or a backroom.

Batra put it plainly:

"Every athlete deserves transparency, consistency and accountability."

And this time, she's not letting it slide.

That's all for now!